Retired MLB star Matt Holliday has placed his stunning custom-built estate in Stillwater, Oklahoma, on the market for $12 million. The property, a true legacy retreat reflecting his successful baseball career and family focus, combines luxury living with top-tier athletic facilities on a sprawling 136-acre gated parcel—making it currently the most expensive single-family home listed in the state.
Holliday, a seven-time All-Star, 2011 World Series champion with the St. Louis Cardinals, and former outfielder who also played for teams like the Colorado Rockies and Oakland Athletics, purchased the land for approximately $3 million before constructing the home in 2022. Now, as the family prepares to relocate to Arizona, they’re offering this one-of-a-kind property to a new owner.
The main residence is a spacious 7,500-square-foot one-story home featuring five bedrooms, six full bathrooms (plus additional half baths in some descriptions), and a four-car garage. It’s designed for comfort and entertainment, with high-end finishes throughout.
What sets this estate apart is its array of sports and recreational amenities tailored to a professional athlete’s lifestyle—and perfect for training the next generation. Highlights include:
- A professionally lit baseball field (also suitable for wiffleball) prominently located in the front yard, where Holliday honed the skills of his sons—including Jackson Holliday, the No. 1 overall pick in the 2022 MLB Draft by the Baltimore Orioles, and other family members who pursued baseball.
- A barn complex equipped with professional batting cages, an indoor pickleball court, and an indoor basketball court.
- A massive gym and additional workout spaces.
- Outdoor features like a private putting green, tennis court, running trails, and an outdoor kitchen.
The crown jewel of the outdoor amenities is a spectacular two-level swimming pool valued at around $2 million, complete with a waterfall, luxury hot tub, and integrated entertainment areas.
This isn’t just a home—it’s a self-contained sports paradise on vast private land, ideal for families passionate about athletics, privacy, and Oklahoma’s wide-open spaces. Located in Stillwater (about an hour north of Oklahoma City and within the Stillwater school district), the property offers seclusion while remaining accessible.
Listed by Wyatt Poindexter of The Agency, the estate is positioned as a “legacy property built for generations,” blending Holliday’s championship pedigree with resort-style luxury. Whether for another sports family, an enthusiast seeking a private compound, or someone drawn to its unique blend of features, this $12 million listing stands out as one of the most distinctive properties currently available in the region.
