Apple TV’s golf comedy Stick continues its second season with a sharply drawn dual narrative that separates its two central figures while deepening the personal stakes for everyone around them. Episode 3, titled “Chip Off the Old Butch,” splits its time between Santi Wheeler’s long-awaited professional debut and Pryce Cahill’s road trip in search of the mentor who once shaped him. The result is one of the season’s most character-driven hours so far, anchored by strong chemistry, pointed humor, and a clear-eyed look at the costs of ambition.
The episode opens with a 1987 flashback in Potosi, Missouri. A younger Butch Lydecker (Tyler Labine) collects a teenage Pryce from the police station after a fight. Butch delivers the blunt warning that has defined Pryce’s life: he possesses rare talent, but wasting it will leave a permanent hole. In the present, that warning still hangs over Pryce as he and Clark Ross (Timothy Olyphant) set out to find the now-elderly Butch in hopes of preparing for a U.S. Open qualifier. Mitts (Marc Maron), having sold his house in anticipation of settling down with Elena, is initially reluctant but joins the journey after personal plans collapse.
Meanwhile, in Los Angeles, Santi (Peter Dager), Zero (Lilli Kay), and Elena (Mariana Treviño) arrive at the offices of the sports management firm Stratus. Agency head Peter Crane and his team welcome “Showtime Wheeler” with the full professional package—housing options, endorsement interest from brands like Mastercard and Under Armour, and a media machine ready to handle his image. Santi’s first-round performance at the Charles Schwab Classic in Arizona (two under par) suggests he is ready for the stage. The surrounding machinery, however, is already altering the dynamics of his inner circle. Zero’s informal role managing his social media is professionalized, and Elena finds herself treated more as a supportive “mom-ager” than a decision-maker. At a sponsor-filled party, both women navigate new social circles with mixed results: Zero is drawn into the world of wives and girlfriends, while Elena grows increasingly aware of the distance forming between her and her son.
Back on the road, the visit to Butch’s farm yields an unexpected reality. The legendary coach (now played by Rex Linn) is living with Alzheimer’s and experiences only intermittent clarity. The stop provides comic relief—most notably when Clark is tased by Butch’s nurse—but also underscores how much has changed. The emotional and narrative centerpiece arrives with Butch’s daughter Amanda (Rhea Seehorn), an old friend of Pryce’s who has returned to care for her father. Amanda is direct and unsentimental. She has already studied Pryce’s recent performance at the Dove Charity Pro-Am and immediately identifies mechanical flaws—poor rotation through impact, a “splashy” swing that prioritizes speed over stability, and the same self-destructive tendencies she remembers from his teenage years. While Clark and Mitts defend Pryce’s talent, Amanda argues that talent alone has never been enough and that a serious run at the U.S. Open at 55 remains a long shot until he confronts the root of his pattern.
Pryce, characteristically, interprets the critique as a job offer. The episode ends with him declaring to Mitts and Clark that Amanda is their new swing coach, even though she has not formally accepted. On the personal front, Mitts and Elena agree to “take a beat” after his house sale and her decision to remain in Los Angeles with Santi’s team leave their plans in disarray. Elena is later shown checking her phone at a party, suggesting the separation is not as clean as either of them claims.
“Chip Off the Old Butch” succeeds because it trusts its ensemble. The Pryce-Mitts-Clark trio develops an easy, lived-in rhythm that makes the road-trip half of the episode consistently engaging, and Rhea Seehorn’s arrival as Amanda immediately raises the stakes with sharp observational humor and unresolved history. Santi’s storyline, while less immediately charming, effectively plants the seeds of future tension by showing how quickly professional success can isolate the people who helped create it. At a lean 37 minutes, the episode moves efficiently, balances golf insight with character work, and leaves both narrative tracks pointed toward compelling questions for the weeks ahead. It is a confident, low-key installment that plays to the series’ strengths.